Stock Markets – Gambling or Investing
October 14, 2008 : Category: Stock Market : Comments (0) : Add CommentIntroduction
Value creation and wealth creation are the most important aspects of stock investment. However, it is a common myth that investing in stock markets is not different from gambling. If you are an investor or a fresh professional seeking a placement in the finance industry, you must understand the basic differences between gambling and investing. Let us try to shatter that myth.
Before going further, it makes sense to review the behavior of Indian stock markets during the period 2003 to 2008 in the context of “Stock markets –Gambling or Investing”.
About Present Indian Stock Markets
Having started its bull phase from 2003, Indian stock markets surged to record high in a very short span. Later half of 2007 witnessed frenzied state in the markets with 1000 points gain every other week. Business channels and news media were in the race to display placards with every 1000 points gain in BSE Sensex.
Every family member was glued to the screens of online trading terminals and cheering up at their fortunes. Every penny stock on the bourse was daily scaling new highs after breaching upward circuit breakers in its first hour of the trade. F&O segment of the market witnessed historical build up of huge amount of open interest. People rarely hesitated in deploying the money kept aside for children’s education to stock markets. Indian stock market was flooded with hot tips, astrologically linked tips, thousands of so-called analysts and experts on the business channels and stock websites.
What did the behavior of hysterical masses demonstrate? Well, it was nothing but a sign of greed, punting, quick bucks, momentum play, gravely inebriated investors (or gamblers?) and disastrous speculation. It is OK until the going gets good.
However, there are some unpleasant truths in the stock markets – markets never move in one direction, markets are not money minting machines and downturn in the market is as fast as the its upmove.
Indian stock markets are presently facing the realities of these unpleasant truths. Markets have crashed during the last eight months from January 2008 onward. Nobody knows the bottom. Hardly anybody wants to speculate the extent of downside left in the markets. Hundreds of experts and millions of investors have vanished from the stock markets.
Status of Indian stock markets as mentioned above strongly supported the myth ‘Stock markets – gambling or investing’ in favor of gambling.
All the same, excesses in the Indian stock markets (or for those matter global stock markets) do not necessarily prove that stock markets are a gambling den. On the contrary, the stock markets have been the biggest wealth creator for millions of investors all over the world.
About Stock markets – Gambling or Investing
How do various dictionaries define gambling and investing?
Gambling – Predicting unpredictable, take a bet on an uncertain outcome, game of chance
Investing – Putting money to work for gainful purposes or for profitable returns or financial returns,
Well, the definitions by themselves do not throw much light on the distinction between gambling and investing. In fact, investing is also a chance, as the stock may not provide the expected returns due to various reasons.
So let us once again try to distinguish between an investor and a gambler. Table given below narrates the basic differences between gambling and investing. I hope it provides a reasonable guidance to you.
| Gambling | Investing |
| Gambling is construed as a morally bad thing (let us keep aside the debate on morality) | Investing is a good thing |
| Gambling rarely makes a positive contribution to the economy of the nation. | Stock investment undoubtedly contributes positively to increased productivity of the company and the overall growth of the economy of the nation |
| Gambler never has to bother on any analysis, research and studies – it is just a game of chance, luck and emotions | Investing demands analysis, studies and research in deriving the intrinsic value of the company and its stock price |
| For most of the times, the odds are against the gambler | Odds in stock investment are more likely to be favorable |
| Gambling is not challenging intellectually | Investing demands skills and intelliegence. |
| Gambling can be addictive and destructive | Investment is generally not addictive and occasionally it can be destructive especially when the company goes bankrupt |
| Gambling is an entertainment and it cannot become a business | Investment has all the necessary ingredients to turn into a successful business |
| Gambling cannot be a tool to achieve specific goals in life | With well-planned investments, it is possible to generate healthy retirement corpus |
| Gamblers are risk takers | Investors are risk-averse |
| Gambling is a short-term exercise | Investing is a long-term and continuous process |
| Gambling does not lead to ownership in a tangible thing | Investment in a stock is an ownership in the company |